Sunday, March 15, 2020

Why? You Tell Me (or at least tell yourself)

by Dan Nagle

In this 2020 primary season, Bernie Sanders tied for first place in the opening presidential contest then won the next two. Joe Biden ran a dismal 4th place in the first contest, finished 5th in the second with only 8% of the vote and was soundly defeated in the third contest. Then, Biden won the 4th presidential contest, South Carolina, defeating Sanders who finished in 2nd place.

The media proclaimed South Carolina a great victory and huge turn around for Biden. Rarely mentioned, however, was the fact that this was no great upset win. Biden was expected to easily win South Carolina, a state where Sanders, in 2016, lost to Hillary Clinton 73% to 26%. Another fact somewhat ignored yet certainly pertinent was that this "great" Biden victory in South Carolina (49%/20%) was almost exactly the same as Bernie's margin the week before in Nevada (47%/20%).

So, exiting South Carolina with Super Tuesday four days away, Joe Biden had so far finished: 4th, 5th, a distant 2nd and then an unsurprising 1st. Bernie Sanders had finished: tied for 1st, 1st, 1st, and a distant 2nd. Sanders was still considered the clear front-runner and was still leading in a healthy majority of Super Tuesday contests, although polls did tighten a bit after South Carolina.

Then, in a flurry, right before Super Tuesday, two candidates, Buttigieg and Klobuchar, dropped from the race and endorsed Biden. Beto O'Rourke, a former candidate, also endorsed Biden.


Why would these three young politicians, with long political careers in front of them, risk their futures by sticking their necks out for a candidate who had so far not only done poorly in the voting but also still trailed in the polls, had stumbled through most debates, left a trail of gaffes and lies in his wake, had little money, no ground game and generated little enthusiasm?

Why would Buttigieg and Klobuchar campaign for a year, garnering a base of supporters and loyal staffers, then drop out right before Super Tuesday, the biggest day of the campaign season? Again, their endorsements were for a candidate who, by most accounts, was a lifeless under-performer in three of the first four contests.

Why, to increase the chances her policies and ideas might survive and move forward, didn't Elizabeth Warren follow the lead of the Biden endorsements and endorse Bernie Sanders, her "brother in beliefs", especially since her campaign was almost broke a month earlier and going nowhere by Super Tuesday? Yes, she and Bernie had their issues with one another but the other candidates who dropped and endorsed had their own "Biden baggage" to unload when they threw their hats in for the former vice president.

Why did the failed Elizabeth Warren campaign suddenly get a Super Pac's backing allowing her to stay in the race through Super Tuesday, which very well looks to have cost Bernie Sanders three states that night (he would have tied Biden with 7 state wins) plus many more delegates in states where the races would have been much closer. This lack of a Super Tuesday movement to Bernie by Warren very arguably tipped the delegate math so much toward Joe Biden that the nomination race was over.


Why did I not answer the previous four questions? Because by now you should have answered them yourself.

Friday, March 13, 2020

Bernie and a Third Party Run?

by Dan Nagle

Until Barack Obama was elected, many people still believed a black person could never become President. Obama did it twice. Then, that historic achievement was immediately followed by an even bigger shocker. Donald Trump, a non-politician outsider, not only won the GOP nomination but won the presidency and took complete, dominate control of the Republican Party.

So, in line with those supposed unlikely events, it's not that far-fetched to think a third party candidate could win a presidential election. Actually, that sort of happened in 1860 when Abe Lincoln won the Presidency in only the fourth year of his party's (Republican) existence. In fact, four different candidates from four different parties won electoral votes in that 1860 election.

In modern history we had a third party candidate, George Wallace in 1968, actually winning five states, 10 million votes overall and 46 electoral votes.

As recently as 1992, Ross Perot got 20 million votes for President and that was after he dropped out in July and reentered only a few weeks before the election. Previous to that 1992 run, Perot was a complete unknown, a hurdle Bernie would not be facing.
 
Just winning California gives a candidate one-fifth of the electoral votes needed to win it all and Sanders is very strong in California. And note, a majority of the popular vote is NOT needed to win a state's electoral votes, only a plurality. For instance, Bernie could win a state with 39% of the vote while, let's say, Trump got 34% and Biden 27%.  So, it's not unreasonable to think that Bernie, based on many big primary wins and close call losses in 2016 and 2020, could win a plurality in many blue states and even make a decent showing in some red states.

Also, Sanders has a strong, well-organized core group and ground game. He has shown he can raise money and polls indicate that his policies have broad support, even across party lines in many cases. Bernie polls well as being trusted, respected and favorable as a candidate. Based on the rules, Bernie Sanders would have to be given a place on the debate stage in a general election. Bernie's dominates with Latinos and owns the 45-and-under demographic. Yes, many in that group stayed home in recent primaries, but it's not outlandish to suggest younger crowds would show up when the big prize is up for grabs.
___________________________________________

Possibilities

1. Bernie Sanders gets millions of votes and wins a few states, likely costing Biden the election and giving Trump a second term. If Donald Trump is weaker than thought, such a performance by Sanders might not cost Biden the election.

2. Bernie gets millions of votes but does not win one state, much less the presidency. However, as stated earlier, many thought a black man and a shady businessman/reality TV star had no chance, so throw traditional thought out the window.

3. Sanders wins enough states to stop both Biden and Trump from getting the 270 electoral votes needed to become President. In this case, the House of Representatives decides, resulting in a Biden presidency since the House is Democratic controlled.

4. Bernie wins it all then faces entrenchment against his policies by both parties who still control all of Congress as well as all 50 state governments.

5. Sanders wins it all but has his election overturned by the Electoral College, the first time in history for such an occurrence.
___________________________________________

The above possibilities are ranked in order of likeliness. But, to repeat it again, our country twice elected a black President and then followed that with Donald Trump, so who knows?

If possibility #5 seems outlandish then consider that a good argument can be made showing, in 2016 and even more so in 2020, the Democratic Party acted as if stopping Bernie Sanders was more important than winning the general election. Additionally though, it would be unfair to pin that sentiment only on the Democratic Party. The Democratic and Republican parties constitute the corporate establishment. Together, they would not stand for a Bernie presidency. 

In 1980's Burlington, Vermont, the local Democratic and Republican parties joined forces to try and stop Sander's reelection. Alas, they failed. Lucky for Bernie, the Electoral College cannot overturn mayoral elections.

Friday, November 22, 2019

House Impeachment Inquiry Reveals Disturbing Truth - U.S. Foreign Service a Corporate Arm


by Dan Nagle

On November 15, While testifying at the House Impeachment Inquiry, former U.S. Ambassador Marie Yovanovitch said,“Obviously, U.S. ambassadors, U.S. embassies, one of our most important functions is to facilitate U.S. business abroad, right? …That's one of the things that we do…we obviously advocate for U.S. business.”

These words were part of a longer answer to a question about ambassadorial duties, posed by GOP attorney, Stephen Castor.

In that same answer, Yovanovitch added: “…That would usually be a first stop (for American corporate interests), going to the American Chamber of Commerce, going to the U.S. Embassy, get the lay of the land, see how we could provide assistance.”

Being this was spoken at an impeachment hearing, no one paid much attention to the remarks since everyone’s focus, and rightfully so, was on possible wrongdoings of the President.   

However, impeachment inquiry aside, Yovanovitch’s statements are disturbing, especially in today’s reality where, for decades now, American workers have been getting less and less of the profits generated by the U.S. economy. Regarding just the past decade, since the Great Recession of 2008, a Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis blog post noted, “Never have corporate profits outgrown employee compensation so clearly and for so long.”1
 
So, why, in an environment where corporate profits are off the charts and workers’ progress is stagnant or regressing, do we have U.S. embassies, ambassadors and staff essentially, and admittedly, working in large part for corporate America?

Could Ambassador Yovanovitch be wrong? Not a chance. She has been an ambassador to three different countries and is a 30+ year employee of the U.S. Foreign Service where she holds a senior ranking. Yovanovitch even said her claim was “obvious”.

Thus, while most people know that the U.S. Foreign Service and their embassies, ambassadors and staff strive to maintain peaceful relationships with other nations, many would be surprised to learn that another of its key duties is facilitating for U.S. business interests in conjunction with the American Chamber of Commerce!

The U.S. State Department has a budget of $52 billion with 45,000 employees. Within the State Department is U.S. Foreign Services, which includes 307 U.S. embassies and 15,000 employees. U.S. Foreign Services takes a huge share of the State Department’s $52 billion budget and, of course, all of this is American tax payer funded.

So, if our State Department’s U.S. Foreign Service system openly admits “one of our most important functions is to facilitate U.S. business abroad”, then why are American workers, who are getting less and less their share of the corporate profit pie, paying taxes to support this? 

Of course, the standard response to that question is: “Because what advances American corporations, advances American workers.” Well, that worn out answer stopped being true decades ago. Corporate advances in profits now come at the expense of worker gains. This is undisputed.  

It seems obvious and fair. If billions go to a U.S. Foreign Service with a mission of advocating for corporate America, then shouldn’t this mission be expanded to include advocating for American workers? Especially since it’s American workers whose taxes are mostly paying for the U.S. Foreign Service and its embassies, ambassadors and staff.

Let's start with any American embassy, staff or ambassador being prohibited from brokering  corporate deals where American workers would lose jobs, such as a U.S. plant relocating overseas or the importation of a product that leads to job losses in the U.S. Additionally, any corporate agreements aided by the U.S. Foreign Service that creates more American jobs or more work for U.S. labor must also include language specifying how such jobs and workers will reasonably share in the profits from these deals.

To add even more to this discussion, look again at Ambassador Yovanovitch’s statement, which seemingly claims the U.S. Foreign Service not only goes to bat for U.S. corporate interests but does so in partnership with the American Chamber of Commerce: 

“That would usually be a first stop, going to the American Chamber of Commerce, going to the U.S. Embassy, get the lay of the land, see how we could provide assistance.” 

With this reality, it's even more imperative something be done to make things more fair for American workers. After all, as Yovanovitch states, the American Chamber of Commerce is involved. This group is a branch of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the nation’s largest lobbying group, a group that accepts funding from a long list of well-known American companies. 

By a large margin, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and its affiliates spend more on lobbying than any other corporation or industry. They are the foremost voice for corporate power in Washington and it’s no secret the Chamber, especially in this 21st century, often leans toward supporting and funding the agenda and policies of the GOP. Such policies include: anti-union measures, fighting equal pay policies, and in general, anything that increases the profits of corporate America, often at the expense of American workers (through stagnant wages and lost benefits).2

In the overall American landscape, the bleak reality of dwindling worker rights, shrinking wages and lost benefits is arguably more serious than a matter of presidential high crimes and misdemeanors. Perhaps it’s fitting then, the bright light of impeachment inadvertently illuminated an economic injustice against the American worker. 

So, politicians, go ahead and decide if the President let our nation down, but then also decide that American workers will no longer be beaten down by a coalition of the U.S. Foreign Service and American Chamber of Commerce.

1 www.nytimes.com, “Paychecks Lag as Profits Soar, and Profits Erode Wage Gains”, Patricia Cohen, July 13, 2018


2 www.racked.com, “The US Chamber of Commerce Might Not Be What You Think”, Corynne Cirilli, Oct 2, 2017

The author, Dan Nagle, is a retired teacher. Besides fairness for workers, he also strives for the fair treatment of our public schools. He created and maintains, "A Public Defense of the Public Schools", a well developed response to the unfair attack on America's public schools. Here is a link...http://publicschooldefender3.blogspot.com/