Sunday, March 15, 2020

Why? You Tell Me (or at least tell yourself)

by Dan Nagle

In this 2020 primary season, Bernie Sanders tied for first place in the opening presidential contest then won the next two. Joe Biden ran a dismal 4th place in the first contest, finished 5th in the second with only 8% of the vote and was soundly defeated in the third contest. Then, Biden won the 4th presidential contest, South Carolina, defeating Sanders who finished in 2nd place.

The media proclaimed South Carolina a great victory and huge turn around for Biden. Rarely mentioned, however, was the fact that this was no great upset win. Biden was expected to easily win South Carolina, a state where Sanders, in 2016, lost to Hillary Clinton 73% to 26%. Another fact somewhat ignored yet certainly pertinent was that this "great" Biden victory in South Carolina (49%/20%) was almost exactly the same as Bernie's margin the week before in Nevada (47%/20%).

So, exiting South Carolina with Super Tuesday four days away, Joe Biden had so far finished: 4th, 5th, a distant 2nd and then an unsurprising 1st. Bernie Sanders had finished: tied for 1st, 1st, 1st, and a distant 2nd. Sanders was still considered the clear front-runner and was still leading in a healthy majority of Super Tuesday contests, although polls did tighten a bit after South Carolina.

Then, in a flurry, right before Super Tuesday, two candidates, Buttigieg and Klobuchar, dropped from the race and endorsed Biden. Beto O'Rourke, a former candidate, also endorsed Biden.


Why would these three young politicians, with long political careers in front of them, risk their futures by sticking their necks out for a candidate who had so far not only done poorly in the voting but also still trailed in the polls, had stumbled through most debates, left a trail of gaffes and lies in his wake, had little money, no ground game and generated little enthusiasm?

Why would Buttigieg and Klobuchar campaign for a year, garnering a base of supporters and loyal staffers, then drop out right before Super Tuesday, the biggest day of the campaign season? Again, their endorsements were for a candidate who, by most accounts, was a lifeless under-performer in three of the first four contests.

Why, to increase the chances her policies and ideas might survive and move forward, didn't Elizabeth Warren follow the lead of the Biden endorsements and endorse Bernie Sanders, her "brother in beliefs", especially since her campaign was almost broke a month earlier and going nowhere by Super Tuesday? Yes, she and Bernie had their issues with one another but the other candidates who dropped and endorsed had their own "Biden baggage" to unload when they threw their hats in for the former vice president.

Why did the failed Elizabeth Warren campaign suddenly get a Super Pac's backing allowing her to stay in the race through Super Tuesday, which very well looks to have cost Bernie Sanders three states that night (he would have tied Biden with 7 state wins) plus many more delegates in states where the races would have been much closer. This lack of a Super Tuesday movement to Bernie by Warren very arguably tipped the delegate math so much toward Joe Biden that the nomination race was over.


Why did I not answer the previous four questions? Because by now you should have answered them yourself.